A frame-by-frame review of the 9-iron swing from the October 28 session at Mariners, filmed down-the-line from behind the hands, with the full ball-flight readout from the range screen. This is 9-Iron report #2. It adds the Birdie GAi scorecard (head, hips, hands, tempo), shoulder and hip turn, and the waist, shoulder, knee and tush reference lines, and it closes with simple next steps.
Bottom line: a solid, tour-like 9-iron flight. 117 yards total, 116 carry, with 92.2 mph of ball speed, just under the LPGA Tour 9-iron average (93 mph). The shape of the flight matches the LPGA averages closely: a 78 ft (26 yd) apex (LPGA 26 yds) and a 47° landing angle (LPGA 47°). Launch is 27°, about 3° higher than the LPGA 23.9°. Carry is 3 yards short of the LPGA average (119). The ball curved only 6 ft to the left. The ball numbers are identical to report #1, so this report is a second, deeper look at the same shot. It sets no new personal best (everything ties report #1).
The swing has one strong habit and one constant. Strong: the hips stay back, with the rear of the hips about 0.2 in from the tush line at impact, and the measured tempo is 3.0:1, right on the Tour Tempo ratio. The constant: the head sits about 5.5 in lower than at address at impact, and most of that drop already happens in the first 0.3 s of the takeaway. The hips also rise about 1.9 in, and the hands return about 2 in from their address spot.
Hips stay on the tush line (about 0.2 in gap at impact) and the swing runs at 3.0:1, the Tour Tempo ratio.
The head is already about 5 in lower at the takeaway and about 5.5 in lower at impact. Keeping the cap on its address line is the one big fix.
Hips rise about 1.9 in and the hands land about 2 in off their address spot. Turning without standing up should bring both back to the 'Good' band.
| Metric | André (Oct 28) | Report #1 (Oct 28) | LPGA Tour avg | PGA Tour avg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ball speed | 92.2 mph | 92.2 mph | 93 mph | 109 mph |
| Club speed (est.) | ~66–67 mph | ~66–67 mph | 72 mph | 85 mph |
| Carry | 116 yds | 116 yds | 119 yds | 148 yds |
| Flat carry | 115 yds | 115 yds | — | — |
| Total | 117 yds | 117 yds | — | — |
| Launch angle | 27° | 27° | 23.9° | 20.4° |
| Spin | — | — | 7589 rpm | 8647 rpm |
| Apex | 78 ft (26 yds) | 78 ft | 26 yds | 30 yds |
| Landing angle | 47° | 47° | 47° | 51° |
| Curve | 6 ft left | 6 ft left | — | — |
| Hang time | 5.2 s | 5.2 s | — | — |
| Proximity | 73 ft | 73 ft | — | — |
No ★ this time: every ball number equals report #1, so nothing beats it. Club speed and spin aren't on the screen. Club speed is estimated from ball speed at a typical iron smash of ~1.38–1.40, which gives about 66–67 mph (LPGA average 72). The screen also shows target markers at 102 and 129 yds. The ball could not be tracked in the video: at 30 frames per second it is gone between two frames after impact. Slow-motion (120 or 240 fps) would let the start direction be measured.
What it means: The flight is almost a copy of the LPGA 9-iron: same apex, same landing angle, ball speed within 1 mph. A launch about 3° above the LPGA average, with the same apex, fits a swing with a bit less speed than the average. The 3-yard carry gap to the LPGA average is small. More ball speed is the long-term way to close the gap to the PGA Tour carry (148), and a steadier head height is the way to make every strike repeat.
30 frames per second, so each time is accurate to about ±0.03 s. The backswing starts at frame 214 (first clear hand movement), the top is at frame 232 (33.23 s) and impact is at frame 238 (33.43 s).
| Group | Backswing | Downswing | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| André (9-iron #2, Oct 28) | ~0.60 s | ~0.20 s | ~3.0:1 |
| André (9-iron #1, Oct 28, as logged) | ~1.23 s | ~0.20 s | ~6.2:1 |
| André (PW #3, Oct 28) | ~0.53 s | ~0.20 s | ~2.7:1 |
| PGA Tour (Tour Tempo, "24/8") | ~0.80 s | ~0.27 s | 3:1 |
Tour figure: John Novosel, Tour Tempo. One frame either way moves the ratio between ~2.6:1 and ~3.6:1. The 6.2:1 in report #1 used a much longer backswing window (1.23 s). This report times the backswing from the first clear hand movement, so most of the difference is how the start is defined, not a new swing.
What it means: A 0.60 s backswing and a 0.20 s downswing is a smooth, well-paced 9-iron, in the 'Good' band (2.5–3.5:1) and in line with his PW (2.7:1) from the same session. The downswing is quick but not rushed, and the same count can be kept in the other irons.
Nine key positions, filmed down-the-line from behind the hands. The target is straight into the picture. Times: address 32.57 s (frame 212), takeaway 32.90 s (222), lead arm parallel 32.97 s (224), top 33.23 s (232), arm parallel down 33.33 s (235), delivery 33.40 s (237), impact 33.43 s (238), release 33.53 s (241), finish 34.43 s (268).
Photos are numbered in the order they happen in the swing. The frames follow the standard swing positions.
| Measure (vs address) | Top | Impact | Report #1 (top / impact) | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Head, down | ~3.8 in | ~5.5 in | — / ~6 in | Fix dip already starts in the takeaway (~5.2 in) |
| Head, toward the ball | ~3.1 in | ~3.0 in | — / — | Watch see depth note |
| Hips, toward the ball | ~−0.7 in (away) | ~−0.1 in | — / hips stay back | Good no early extension |
| Rear of hips vs tush line | — | ~0.2 in gap | — / ~0.2 in | Good stays on the line |
| Hips, rise | ~0.4 in | ~1.9 in | — / ~1.8 in | Watch standing up a little |
| Hands at impact vs address | — | ~2.0 in | — / ~0.7 in | Watch a bit farther than report #1 |
| Shoulder turn | ~85° | ~10° open | ~85° / — | Info full turn (±10–15°) |
| Hip turn | ~40° | ~30° open | ~40° / — | Info hips clear ahead of the shoulders |
| X-factor (shoulders − hips) | ~45° | — | ~45° / — | Info good coil, same as report #1 |
| Tempo (back : down) | ~3.0:1 | — | ~6.2:1 (longer window) | Good on Tour Tempo |
Depth note: with only one stick on the target line, no vanishing point can be computed, and the mat-edge depth rays are only a rough guide. From behind, the head's ~3 in shift toward the ball is a mix of 'toward the ball' and 'toward the target', and one camera can't split the two. A face-on clip of the next swing will settle it (see Limitations).
| Club (best report) | Total | Carry | Ball speed | Launch | Curve |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 7-Iron · Oct 14 | 147 yds | 144 yds | 104 mph | 22° | 0 ft |
| 9-Iron · Oct 28 | 117 yds | 116 yds | 92.2 mph | 27° | 6 ft left |
| Pitching Wedge · Oct 28 | 115 yds | 113 yds | 89.2 mph | 28° | 15 ft left |
Heads-up: the 9-iron carried only 3 yards more than the pitching wedge (116 vs 113) and finished just 2 yards farther in total (117 vs 115), with 3 mph more ball speed. Neighbouring clubs usually sit about 10 yards apart, so the pitching wedge swing, or this 9-iron, may have been a little off its normal. A few more balls with each will show the real gap. The 8-iron has no report yet and sits in the 30-yard hole between the 7-iron (147) and the 9-iron (117).
Confidence: high on ball flight (range screen, all values legible) and tempo (measured frame by frame); moderate on head, hip and hand distances (grid scaled from body size, ±1 inch); moderate-to-low on shoulder and hip turn (visual estimates, ±10–15°); low on the toward-ball vs toward-target split (needs a second angle) and on the club ID (not readable in the video).
Same camera spot. Keep the top of the cap on the white address line through the takeaway and until the ball is gone, for 10 balls. Film at least the first 1.5 s of each swing.
Feel: 'chest over the ball, knees keep their flex.' The dip starts in the first 0.3 s, so that is where to look.
Make 5 slow swings, then 5 balls, keeping the belt buckle at the same height from address to impact. Check the hip rise (aim for under 1 in).
Less rise means the hands don't have to rescue the strike, which brings them back to the address spot.
Count 'back-2-3, down-1' in the same rhythm as this swing (0.60 s back, 0.20 s down).
It is already a Tour Tempo ratio (3:1) and also fits the PW (2.7:1).
Whatever he does to keep the hips back: keep it. The rear of the hips stays within ~0.2 in of the tush line through impact.
No early extension in the 9-iron, a real strength to build the other irons on.
Next capture: Next capture, to sharpen the reference frame: (1) the same down-the-line spot with two sticks on the target line so a vanishing point can be computed, (2) a face-on clip at chest height, (3) the whole mat in the frame, (4) slow-motion (120 or 240 fps) so the ball can be tracked, (5) 3–5 balls for an average, and (6) André's height, to lock the grid scale.